Why Most Service Businesses Get Crushed in the Algorithm—and How to Build Smarter

Losing traffic after a Google Core update usually means your content wasn't the best option—not that you were penalized. Google's algorithm rewards depth, clarity, and user value, not surface-level SEO tactics or checklist content. If a single update tanks your funnel, it’s a sign your system relied too heavily on one fragile source instead of building lasting authority and trust.

Enjoyed this post? Share it on socials 👇🏻

Let’s be clear about one thing:

Google doesn’t owe you traffic.

It doesn’t owe you leads.

It doesn’t owe you rankings, clicks, or visibility just because you showed up with a blog post and some alt tags.

If your traffic tanked after an update, it’s not sabotage—it’s exposure.

In fact, if a single algorithm change can kill your entire funnel, you didn’t build a business.

You built a dependency.

The Entitlement Problem

There’s a quiet belief that still lingers in founder circles:

“If I publish consistently, follow SEO best practices, and check the boxes—Google will reward me.”

That might’ve worked in 2012. It’s a different game now.

The problem isn’t that Google changed. The problem is that most businesses are still building content for the old internet—where volume and checklists were enough to win.

But today?

Google’s algorithm has evolved.

Take this site for example, thriving and making 5 digits/month on ad traffic alone. After the Google Core Update, traffic tanked.

It’s not looking for “content.” It’s looking for the best possible answer—backed by signals of credibility, depth, and usability.

Here’s what that actually looks like:

You don’t get SEO credit for effort.

You get visibility when your content proves it’s the best solution for the user, not for you.

That means:

Because no matter how much time you’ve spent on that blog post—If it’s not the best answer…you don’t deserve to rank.

What No One Tells You About Organic Growth

You are not entitled to free exposure.

You are not guaranteed a spot on page one.

And no matter how much effort you’ve poured into your site, you are not immune to irrelevance.

Organic growth isn’t a right. It’s a reward.

But too many founders treat SEO like a vending machine:

“I publish the blog, I add the keywords, I press the button… and traffic shows up, right?”

Not quite.

Because organic growth doesn’t just measure output. It measures alignment—between what your audience wants, what your content delivers, and how well your site makes that experience frictionless.

Most businesses only realize this after their traffic tanks or their leads dry up.

And when that happens, the instinct is to blame the algorithm.

But the algorithm didn’t sabotage you.

It just got better at spotting the difference between relevant and replaceable.

If your organic growth has plateaued, the real culprit usually lives here:

Google didn’t ghost you.

You just stopped being the best option.

What to Do Instead (The Continental Way)

So—what actually works now?

If you want to earn visibility and leads in today’s market, you need more than content.

You need a system that proves your relevance, builds trust at scale, and drives action without guesswork.

That’s what we build.

At The Continental, we don’t chase trends. We build lean, conversion-first ecosystems for service-based brands that are done playing small.

Here’s what that looks like:

1. Build Content That Solves, Not Fills Space

We don’t publish just to stay active.

We publish to become the most useful thing on the internet for the person you want to reach.

That means content that shows up at the right time, solves the right problem, and quietly proves that we know exactly what we’re doing.

Authority-first content isn’t about more posts.

It’s about the right ones—written to rank, resonate, and drive action.

Content That Fills Space Content That Builds Authority
Top 10 Marketing Tips for Small Businesses How We Helped a Consultant Triple Leads with One Funnel Fix
Why Blogging Still Matters in 2024 The Only 3 Blog Posts We Recommend for Service-Based Founders
How to Write Better Emails (with no examples) 5 Email Subject Lines That Generated 45%+ Open Rates (and Why They Worked)
The Basics of SEO (rewritten a million times) How We Recovered a Client’s Traffic After a Google Update (Case Breakdown)
Blog post ends with: Let us know what you think Ends with: Want results like this? Book a Strategy Sprint

That’s what we build:

Because at the end of the day, you don’t need content that looks good on your calendar. You need content that actually provides value and attracts the kind of traffic you need.

2. Create Topical Authority, Not Random Articles

You don’t need 100 blog posts.

You need five that go deep enough to make it painfully obvious you know your space better than anyone else.

Most service-based businesses fall into the content trap:

Publishing scattered, surface-level articles in hopes that one of them hits.

But Google doesn’t reward randomness. It rewards relevance + depth.

Random Strategy vs. Topical Authority (Example)

Random Blog Topics Topical Authority Cluster
Website Design Trends in 2024 How to Fix a Coaching Offer That Won’t Sell
Finding Your Business Niche 3 Messaging Mistakes That Kill Premium Conversions
Branding vs. Marketing Explained What Makes Authority Positioning Stick (And How to Nail Yours)

Let’s say you’re a brand strategist for coaches.

Instead of writing about:

You focus on one tight, profitable topic cluster like: Positioning for High-Ticket Coaching Offers

And you build 3–5 posts that go deep:

Suddenly, Google sees you as the go-to source.

Your audience sees it too.

Topical authority doesn’t mean creating more—it means showing up with clarity and owning the conversation.

Because being broad makes you blend in.

But going deep?

That’s what makes you the one they trust (and hire).

3. Stop Relying on One Channel

SEO isn’t a strategy. It’s a channel.

And no single channel—on its own—is going to build a predictable, scalable client pipeline.

Most founders go all in on one platform:

It’s fragile. It burns you out. And it leaves money on the table.

Multichannel Growth Engine | The Continental.png

For example, here at The Continental, we build systems that mix:

Each piece supports the others.

No single algorithm controls your funnel. No content goes to waste.

Because the goal isn’t “being on every platform.”

The goal is building a system that works everywhere you show up.

4. Build for Conversion, Not Just Traffic

Traffic is a vanity metric if it doesn’t lead somewhere.

It doesn’t matter if you get 10,000 monthly visitors if none of them become leads, clients, or even conversations.

High traffic with zero conversions? That’s just noise. 

And noise doesn’t pay the bills.

Most content falls flat because it lacks direction.

The reader finishes the blog post, email, or landing page and thinks: “cool…now what?”

And if you’re not telling them what to do next, Google won’t help them figure it out.

Here’s how we fix that:

Every piece of content has a job: to guide someone toward the next step—not just educate or entertain.

That might be:

We don’t just optimize for keywords—we optimize for outcomes.

Because in our world, good content doesn’t just get seen.

It contributes to your bottomline.

Google’s Job Is To Serve Its Users, Not Your Business.

It doesn’t owe you clicks just because you published something.

It won’t protect your rankings just because you followed the rules.

So stop expecting free traffic.

Start building a system that earns attention—because it’s better, sharper, and more useful than what’s already out there.

One that:

That’s what strategic marketing looks like.

That’s the work.

And that’s what we do.

More Tips on the Blog...

The Secret AI Traffic Source Your Competitors Aren’t Using

The Secret AI Traffic Source Your Competitors Aren’t Using

AI tools like ChatGPT, Gemini, and Perplexity already drive traffic to websites. But it often goes unnoticed in GA4. To find this hidden traffic, use a regex filter in GA4’s Traffic Acquisition report targeting known AI referrers like “chatgpt,” “perplexity,” or “gemini.google.” This lets you identify which AI tools are sending traffic and which pages they’re surfacing, helping you build on what’s already working.

Mikel Resaba
On 06/03/2025
What to Expect in the First 90 Days with a Fractional CMO

What to Expect in the First 90 Days with a Fractional CMO

How to spot red flags, capture early wins, and set the foundation for real marketing leadership.

Mikel Resaba
On 05/03/2025
Why SEO-First Publishing Fails — And What to Do Instead

Why SEO-First Publishing Fails — And What to Do Instead

Most SEO-first content fails to drive real results. Discover why keyword-heavy strategies fall flat—and how to create content that ranks, resonates, and converts long term.

Mikel Resaba
On 04/25/2025

Is Your Marketing Budget Burning a Hole in Your Pocket with No Results to Show?

Book an initial consultation and grab our bulletproof marketing framework for free.

Your Brand Deserves the High Table Treatment.